Advertisers can't create needs
I've enjoyed a number of interesting conversations with advertising fans and critics about the creation of needs. My own position? Advertisers can't create needs, or desires, or even wants. They can only play with what hungers already exist within us.
I'm not referring to how planned obsolescence and the advertising associated with it creates need. I'm referring to the belief that advertisers can actually create a need from scratch - ex nihilo, if you will.
For example, is "bad breath" real, or is it a manufactured issue that helps to sell breath mints and Listerine?
6 comments:
I think there's another reality that has to be considered: The Client reality.
For most of us advertisers. We're simply stuck in a situation of limitation: Whatever clients our agency is capable of securing, we get the responsibility of doing work for. We may have a little say in it, but unless you're a salesman or the director of the agency, it seems like we get very little say of what we actually get to advertise.
(I say this from an Art Director's perspective)
Sam,
As I watched Benjamin Barber on Bill Moyer's Journal, I found myself exclaiming, "Amen!"
He said, "Capitalism is no longer manufacturing goods to meet real needs and human wants. It's manufacturing needs to sell us all the goods it's got to produce."
Joshua,
Here's to being influential, regardless of where you stand on your agency's ladder.
Bob,
I watched the interview with Benjamin Barber (author of Consumed). Good stuff. It's hard to cheer for advertising when someone points out its faults like that, but there are enough redeemable qualities for me to continue promoting its improvement and calling it to serve as a Kingdom-reflecting social communicator.
Thanks for the link!
Thanks, Sam. Thanks for getting together with me on Saturday, too. I really appreciated it.
My pleasure, Joshua. Sometime I'll have to see some of your work.
{"but there are enough redeemable qualities for me to continue promoting its improvement and calling it to serve as a Kingdom-reflecting social communicator."}
I agree. If only advertisers used this artform and science to promote innovative goods and services for the common good instead of trying to create needs in order to drum up a market for stuff they already want to sell.
Post a Comment